Gifting Guides

Secret Santa Gift Ideas: Plants and Flowers That Beat a Mug

by Cindy TaylorLead Florist8 min read
Wrapped gift tied with red ribbon beside evergreen branches

The best Secret Santa gift ideas for an office are small living plants, matched to three things you can check before you buy: the price cap, the light at the desk, and who's waiting at home. A potted moth orchid (Phalaenopsis) or a cast-iron plant will outlast the holiday break. The ASPCA lists both as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses. Shop moth orchids are rarely fragrant, too, which counts in a scent-free workplace. For a Toronto office, Cindy's Flowers delivers potted white Phalaenopsis orchids and hand-tied bouquets across the city and the GTA, same-day on orders placed before 3 PM.

What can a Secret Santa price cap actually buy?

At a $25 cap, a small potted plant, not a delivered bouquet. Wikipedia describes Secret Santa as a tradition in which "members of a group are randomly assigned a person to whom they give a gift," and it names no typical spending limit. That $25 comes from a 2016 Accountemps survey of more than 300 Canadian HR managers, who cited it as the average employees and managers should spend on gifts.

Treat it with care. It's from 2016, and it covers office gift-giving in general rather than Secret Santa draws. Cindy's Flowers hand-ties bouquets from $49, roughly double, so a delivered florist gift belongs to a higher cap, a pooled gift, or a separate present.

The pooled gift often lands on a manager, and most HR managers in the survey were comfortable with that. In it, 64% said it's appropriate for workers to give the boss a holiday gift, though most of them added that it depends on the work relationship. Another 32% called it inappropriate, most of those because it can seem like currying favour. Supervisors giving staff a gift split almost the same way, 62% to 33%. When three or four people split one good plant for the team lead, nobody looks like they're angling.

As for the mug itself, Accountemps has a cautionary entry. Among the most inappropriate gifts the managers reported seeing was "A mug with a dirty joke on it." Nobody has ever had to explain a cast-iron plant to HR.

Cut flowers or a plant on a December desk

A plant wins in most offices, because of when the exchange happens. Missouri Botanical Garden puts moth orchid blooms at two to six months, and two to three is the realistic result on a windowsill, as our guide to how long orchids bloom sets out. That carries a gift through the holiday shutdown and well into January. A bouquet handed over on the last day before the break sits in an empty office until the lights come back on.

Cut flowers aren't the wrong idea, just a timing-dependent one. They shine when the exchange falls with a week of workdays still to go, or when the recipient is heading straight home with them. They also need a vase, and a shared office kitchen rarely has a spare. The point our hostess gift guide makes about loose stems at a dinner party holds at a desk too: flowers should arrive ready to stand up.

How the two compare in late December:

  • A potted plant keeps going through the break, travels home in one piece, and needs no vase.
  • A cut bouquet makes a bigger show on the day, but wants fresh water every few days and someone around to change it.

If the calendar does favour cut flowers, our Christmas flower collection is the place to start. For anything handed over on the final day before the shutdown, pick the plant.

Which low-light office plants make good Secret Santa gifts?

Start with the cast-iron plant (Aspidistra elatior) or the parlour palm (Chamaedorea elegans). Clemson's Home & Garden Information Center lists both among its low-light plants, and the ASPCA lists both as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses (the parlour palm under its Bamboo Palm entry). Neither is flashy, which on a shared desk is no bad thing.

For a desk whose owner has no pets or small children, there's the ZZ plant. NC State Extension says it "will grow in very low levels of light, even in areas with only fluorescent light," though it does best in bright indirect sun. The catch is toxicity. NC State flags it as a problem for cats and dogs, and as poisonous to people at medium severity (vomiting and diarrhoea if the leaves are eaten in quantity). The ASPCA has no entry for it.

Several office regulars come with a warning attached. The ASPCA lists the Chinese evergreen, peace lily, snake plant and golden pothos as toxic to dogs, cats and horses (for the last three, the horse listing sits on its Mauna Loa Peace Lily, Golden Bird's Nest and Devil's Ivy entries). The peace lily's name misleads people. It isn't a true lily, and that doesn't make it a safe swap: its calcium oxalate crystals are a problem in their own right.

A moth orchid wants more light than any of these. Give it a desk near an east-facing window, or within a few feet of a brighter one. Our guide to the best indoor plants for Canadian homes sorts species by window, and explains why a room that looks bright can still be dim to a plant.

Does a scent-free office rule out flowers?

Not by name, but it rules out more gifts than most people expect. The Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety (CCOHS) says "there is no exact definition for scent-free, fragrance-free or unscented." Its list of scented products takes in candles, potpourri and air fresheners, and pollen shows up among the other triggers people report.

That puts the classic fallback present, the scented candle, on the wrong side of the line. CCOHS also states that environmental sensitivity "is recognized as a disability. Accommodation is required under the federal and provincial Human Rights Acts." So a Secret Santa gift that sets off a coworker's sensitivity is more than a small faux pas. Ask whoever runs the exchange before you buy anything with a smell.

CCOHS doesn't mention bouquets, so read your own workplace's policy rather than assuming a ban. Where it's strict, skip the fragrant winter bulbs. Iowa State University Extension notes that the paperwhite varieties it covers all have a musky fragrance, except 'Grand Soleil d'Or', which smells sweet and fruity. The ASPCA also lists Narcissus, paperwhites included, as toxic to dogs, cats and horses.

The moth orchid is the quiet choice. The American Orchid Society says "it is unusual to encounter a fragrant example among the ubiquitous hybrid swarms" of Phalaenopsis sold in shops, and that fragrant ones "tend to have a delicate scent that is not heady." Unusual isn't never, so don't promise anyone it's unscented. If you'd rather skip blooms altogether, a foliage plant such as the cast-iron plant keeps the gift green.

What if your Secret Santa goes home to a cat or dog?

Give a potted Phalaenopsis, since a desk gift goes home eventually. The ASPCA lists the Phalaenopsis orchid as "Non-Toxic to Dogs, Non-Toxic to Cats, Non-Toxic to Horses." In the Cindy's Flowers catalogue, the potted Phalaenopsis is the pick for a home with a dog or cat, and a white Phalaenopsis orchid looks as right on a reception desk as on a bookshelf.

Bouquets are another matter, ours included. Eucalyptus, which the ASPCA lists as toxic to dogs, cats and horses, turns up in many of our arrangements, and mixed bouquets change with what the market has that week. So don't treat any bouquet as the animal-friendly option, a rose one included.

December's best-known plants mostly sit on the other list. Poinsettia, amaryllis and hyacinths are all ASPCA-listed as toxic to dogs, cats and horses, the last two often given as boxed bulbs. The poinsettia is milder than its reputation, as our guide to Christmas plants that last explains, but it's still not a pet pick.

True lilies and daylilies are worse. They're highly toxic to cats, pollen and vase water included, so they shouldn't go into a cat's home at all. Our post on whether lilies are poisonous to cats has the detail.

Floor, suite and lobby desk: delivering to an office tower

Order it to arrive a working day early, addressed the way a courier would want it. Cindy's Flowers delivers Monday to Saturday across Toronto and the GTA, same-day on orders placed before 3 PM. Order before 3 PM the day before the exchange and it goes out same-day, so the gift waits at the office overnight instead of turning up mid-party.

From a Bay Street tower to a Mississauga office park, the same details decide whether it reaches the right desk:

  • A full address. The recipient's name as it appears at work, plus the company, the floor and the suite number.
  • The building's routine. Some towers hold deliveries at a lobby desk or mailroom instead of sending them upstairs. Ask reception which yours does.
  • The secret. Have it delivered to yourself, then add it to the pile.
  • A Monday exchange. Order for Friday, because on a Saturday the floor is most likely locked, with nobody upstairs to take the gift in.
  • A hybrid week. If your person works from home that week, send it to their house instead. Same-day delivery covers the GTA.

One last kindness: tell the recipient to keep the plant wrapped for the walk to the subway in December. Then point them to our orchid care guide for the watering, and let the plant do what no Secret Santa mug ever has: grow, well into the new year.

Frequently asked

A small living plant usually beats the mug, the candle and the novelty socks. A potted moth orchid suits a desk near a window. Missouri Botanical Garden puts its blooms at two to six months, and about two to three is realistic indoors, long enough to outlast the holiday break. The ASPCA lists Phalaenopsis as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses. Cindy's Flowers delivers potted white Phalaenopsis orchids across Toronto and the GTA.

You might also like